Where am I?

HOME
  • COMMENT Blogs

Peter Stothard - Times Online - WBLG

June 01, 2009

One dodo after another

Atgre The 'travel issue' of the TLS that goes to press tomorrow is, as you'd expect, not the normal summer holiday guide. Our TLS-travellers fabricate absurd histories for other peoples (Arthur Evans in Crete); or they love Florence but hate the Florentines (almost every nothern European in 1900);  or they visit Mauritius and kill all the dodos; and many more tales of bad trips besides.

The dodo is sometimes seen as an especially baleful example of travelling man's destruction of non-travelling non-man. But this famously extinct creature, whose last relics are pored at every day by Alice-in-Wonderland tourists in Oxford's Natural History Museum, is, instead, one of very many.

Most holidaying bird-lovers have their own favourites on their lists - or rather no longer on their lists. A decade ago OUP published a miserably titled and magnificently illustrated  book, Extinct Birds, in which Errol Fuller set out the full picture of the destruction, including one of the most horrific and absurd losses, one that has always stuck in my own mind and which occurred in the last thirty years.

The Atitlan Grebe can only be imagined now. It was part of my imaginings this morning because I woke up to a particularly magnificent display on the Thames by its more sucessful Great Crested cousin.

 The black-and-white flightless Aitilan was last seen in 1987. It was extinguished by Pan Am (now, appropriately enough, an extinct airline), holidaying fishermen who wanted bigger fish, holidaying souvenir-seekers who wanted more rush mats and, as is so often the way, by flying grebe tourists who saw a better life on a high Guatemalan lake than they had at home.

All grebes are amazing creatures, as I once tried to explain in the TLS myself. They have more feathers than any other birds. Many of them eat their feathers so that their stomachs can be constantly  scoured of the disgusting other stuff they eat. Both sexes carry their young on their back. Indeed both sexes share almost all child-care functions - as is vigorously visible on the Thames.

The Atitlán Grebe was first described in 1929 by the American ornithilogist Ludlow Griscom. The population seems never to have been high and dropped from about 200 to 80 as a result of competition and predation by large-mouth bass introduced into the lake in 1960 to attract Pan Am's frequent flying fishermen.

 Atitlan numbers recovered to a high of 232 in 1975 when the bass, which fed off the grebes' favourite crabs, were themselves reduced by rod and line. But the loss of breeding sites to mat-making reed-cutters and other tourism development set them back. So did the murder  of a government game warden in 1982 and falling lake levels following an earthquake.

Both man and nature, it seemed, were against the Atitlan Grebe. Its pied-bill cousins, smaller but able to fly, arrived for a campaign of vigorous inter-breeding. In 1980 there were fifty left on the mile-high Lake Atitlan which gave the bird its name. In 1983 there were 32. In 1987 another name was added to the Dodo-list.

Some eighty bird species have expired since the seventeenth century when the Mauritius remains headed off for Oxford and a few  travellers started noticing. I don't suppose tourism can be blamed for every loss. Before I read further into OUP's Extinct Birds, there are just a few more details to be fixed on the TLS travel issue that will be winging its way to subscribers on Wednesday.

Posted by Peter Stothard on June 01, 2009 at 21:33 in Books | Permalink | Comments (2)

January 24, 2009

A lesbian, a bi-sexual, a wrist-slasher or a good laugh?

My friends at the Toronto Globe and Mail have begun a new series called Buried Treasures, a search for 'wonderful books that have either been neglected, forgotten or ignored'.

Where's my list?

Any genre is allowed, they say.

The choice does not have to be too obscure :  in the first of the series Jane Urquhart chooses Penelope Fitzgerald's The Blue Flower, certainly  a 'wonderful book' but one which I do hear talked about from time to time.

So, in the same spirit, I am going to offer one of the following to the T G and M, the product of a pleasant Saturday morning  at home in some not recently visited shelves of fiction.

In order of publication date:

David Storey's Flight into Camden, 1960: a northern father accuses his son of  'educated emptiness', a terrifying attack scene which haunted me for years. Magnificent,  but I'm just not sure I want to experience it again.

Brigid Brophy's The Finishing Touch, 1963: rather more agreeable pages of a princess's arrival in a lesbian finishing school in France. Short and redolent of green and yellow chartreuse.

Susan Hill's In the Springtime of the Year, 1973, a masterpice of autobiographical misery, possibly not quite 'neglected, forgotten or ignored' enough. Which is probably a blessing for any Canadian who is depressed enough already without this recommendation.

William Donaldson's Both the Ladies and the Gentlemen, 1975, the memoir of an amateur brothel-keeper starring police officers, lawyers and editors alongside Disgusting Deirdre and Carwash Carol: the funniest book I had ever read, or so I thought at the time. A chance to go back to it now?

Julian Barnes's Fiddle City, 1981, published under the pseudonym, Dan Kavanagh: a bisexual detective takes on the the thiefs of Heathrow: there are also Donaldsonesque scenes in Dude's club in Soho but, thinking more about this problem now, I might change course and  go for a different Brigid Brophy, the absolute airport classic, In Transit. This is getting all more complex than I thought.

Martin Amis's Night Train, 1997: 'I am a police' begins the central character, a female officer called Mike. Genre novels by literary writers are good candidates for 'neglect'. This one is more serious than Barnes's - fewer clubs and more cosmic explanations for suicide - but less obsessively gloomy than the Storey or the Hill. So perhaps this should get the nod for the G and M.

All the copies in front of me now date from my thankfully abandoned book-collecting phase of life. So it's tempting to include a bit of market-sensitivity to the decision.

 My guess is that the Barnes would be the most valuable, though some collectors may still  like, as I did once, the pale blue Cape proof copies of an Amis, promising booksellers a '24-copy dumpbin', and an  'author poster' with their orders. The Hill is a rare book in having no words on its front or back cover, only a William Morris wallpaper pattern. David Storey is out of favour. The Brophy and the Donaldson both show nipples with variant degrees of discretion.

Next week, I'll talk to Toronto and see if any of these fit the bill.

Posted by Peter Stothard on January 24, 2009 at 13:58 in Books | Permalink | Comments (5)

January 08, 2009

Father Brown stories for hard times

Gox It is tempting to wonder what G.K Chesterton's Father Brown would have made of an American pancake house where at one of the late-night tables  there was a man dressed as his creator.

The little priest was famed for solving crimes from a distance, from the other side of a crowded room, when everyone was ignoring him.

A recent bulletin from the American Chesterton Society - which I discovered by accident while seeking  the estate agent's site founded by the author's father - explains that the pancake scene occurrs after a meeting to discuss a new radio recording of that great Father Brown story, The Honour of Israel Gow.

Whether the detective priest would have believed this I rather doubt. There would have to have been a better explanation of an Edwardian gentleman with a beard in a whipped-cream-and-waffle house.

He would surely have had an answer to a G.K Chesterton mystery as strange as this one.

Continue reading "Father Brown stories for hard times" »

Posted by Peter Stothard on January 08, 2009 at 18:54 in Books | Permalink | Comments (2)

December 22, 2008

A TLS is for life

Tomc There is still time to choose a subscription to the TLS as the perfect present for the loved ones who you think 'have everything' but, until they have their regular TLS, truly do not.

In the best festive spirit I've been flicking through alternative gift suggestions in Just What I've Always Wanted by my old friend, the Oxford writer and photographer, Robin Laurance.

Every date is associated in this book with its own gift.

Today, for example, he notes the birthday of Mary Archer, scientist wife of Jeffrey, and how she once celebrated her secretary's birthday with 'an inch of flat champagne'.

Yesterday it was Stalin's birthday - and an opportunity to learn how Beria's wife treated her homicidal husband's homicidal boss to 'a pot of her walnut jam'.

Four days ago, Tom Cruise's wife, Katie Holmes, marked her arrival in the world: a chance for her to remember the time she got 'a compendium of every movie he had made, including those in which he has sex with his former wife, Nicole Kidman'.

Tomorrow? Something for Queen Sylvia of Sweden. You really don't want to know what.

Christmas Eve? An Afghan bicycle.

Christmas Day. A bedroom of musicians premiering the Siegfried Idyll.

Gifts are tough. Robin proves it.

There is still time to buy his book, I suppose. I recommend it.

But make it even easier for yourself. Just give the TLS.

Happy Holidays to all - with an extra something Mrs Wagner might not have liked so much as her Christmas morning Idyll.

Posted by Peter Stothard on December 22, 2008 at 17:08 in Books | Permalink | Comments (1)

November 29, 2008

Oscar Wilde's Woolies

Oxfordstreet1 There is both a Woolworth and an MFI store in Oxford - but neither of them is in Oxford Street.

So, London's 'premier place to shop' is not affected directly by the financial collapse of two of the country's best known retailers.

I am sure there used to be a Woolworth on Oxford Street. I bought a black tie there once when I needed one in a hurry for a funeral.

I could use the rest of this blog to post all sorts of nostalgic Woolworth nonsense about pick n' mix fruit-sweets and my 'first Acker Bilk LP'.

Why not? Everyone else has. This has been 'Save Our Woolies' week - with even Treasury ministers forced into reminiscence about their earliest Christmas Toys policy.

Meanwhile, poor MFI has had only abuse, departing the great retail stage only to a long queue of jokes about flat-pack beds and 'final, final, final sale prices'.

I don't have any MFI stories.

Anyway, why pretend?

On a blog there is no need to lie, or in my case to join the general lament to dead shops. So I won't.

Continue reading "Oscar Wilde's Woolies" »

Posted by Peter Stothard on November 29, 2008 at 22:06 in Books | Permalink | Comments (4)

November 24, 2008

What Hugo Young left behind

HypThe 'Editor's diary' was still an object of veneration when I first arrived at The Times in 1981 but, like many such objects, had not been generally seen for some time.

What was it? The secrets of the editorial lunch table or the duty rota for the night staff? I would sometimes wonder.

After the TLS review last week of the Hugo Young Papers, several inquirers have queried how truly abnormal was Hugo's practice of making a record of lunch conversations with politicians for later use.

Surely, these questioners asked, the writing-up of notes must have been a more common post-prandial activity - of editors and of columnists - than I had said.

Other may know better than I.

Certainly, the sacred 'Editor's diary' at The Times was not anything to have generated the interest this weekend that Hugo Young's posthumously published lunch notes from 1969-2003 have fired.

The diary kept in the office by John Thadeus Delane, Thomas Chenery and George Earle Buckle from the mid-nineteenth century to the First World War was barely more than list of who had written each of the unsigned leading articles.

Continue reading "What Hugo Young left behind" »

Posted by Peter Stothard on November 24, 2008 at 13:13 in Books | Permalink | Comments (2)

November 22, 2008

Classic Clive James

Krissykeefer_dance What are your three favourite poems of all those you've published in the TLS?

The first time I was asked that question I froze.

Listophobia again.

On the second time of asking I answered that at the top of the list was Clive James's The Magic Wheel, which appeared in the TLS in the issue before Christmas four years ago.

I remembered it most of all, I had to admit, because it was, in the poet's words, 'an ode in the manner of Theocritus'.

It was version of a classic - but an unusual, genuinely unforgettable, one.

Continue reading "Classic Clive James" »

Posted by Peter Stothard on November 22, 2008 at 21:10 in Books | Permalink | Comments (6)

November 18, 2008

Blood in the mud

Norsu_veri The final volume of Simon Hornblower's Commentary on Thucydides arrived in the TLS yesterday.

The classics section of our books table contains often many a fine contribution. But there is something always compelling to me about a paragraph-by-paragraph critique of a very great work, particularly the pages about the most famous bits, the passages that, when first read, were horrifying or inspiring or both.

What new is there to say about the last days of the Sicilian Expedition, the catastrophic imperialist adventure of the Athenian democracy, the invasion so often invoked to criticise Hitler in Russia, Bush in Iraq and many other moves that ended their eras?

Continue reading "Blood in the mud" »

Posted by Peter Stothard on November 18, 2008 at 21:59 in Books | Permalink | Comments (4)

November 15, 2008

A hoax in time

Longitude What mixture of the metaphorical and the merely physical makes books about time so horribly long-lasting?

Stephen Hawking's A Brief History of Time (1988) is one of the most dependable exhibits at any Oxfam store.

But Dava Sobel's Longitude (1995) is more ubiquitous by far, providing many a stable retail perch for 'art deco' brandy-glasses (set of three: no reasonable offer refused).

Moreover, simple reliance on the charity-shop test is to ignore the millions of copies of both books that are yellowing in the nation's lavatory libaries on the off-chance that their import might eventually be appreciated in full.

This week the TLS has offered some surprising help.

Continue reading "A hoax in time" »

Posted by Peter Stothard on November 15, 2008 at 19:08 in Books | Permalink | Comments (2)

November 06, 2008

My Crooked Sixpence

Sayle0 Congratulations to TLS contributor Murray Sayle on the news that readers finally have the chance to read his Fleet Street classic, A Crooked Sixpence, almost fifty years after the whole print-run was pulped to avoid a libel action.

My bright yellow 1960 copy is on the desk in front of me now  - and, by all accounts, it is one of very few survivors.

The excellent Roy Greenslade has been running a daily Guardian summary of the plot this week, rejoicing that a portrait of the red-top press in its yellowest heyday is back now to educate a new generation.

Richard Kay in The Daily Mail has explained the saga of the author's 'friend' who thought back in 1960 that he could get some cash from the publisher's libel insurers.

And a publisher has a new paperback edition that will soon be here to join its hardback original at the TLS - now that the opportunist 'friend' is dead,

Both booksellers and journalists tend to exaggerate when it comes to claiming an edition's rarity.

Perhaps there were many survivors of the legal flames.

But I'm taking now that special pleasure in reading the book here in hardback as it was originally intended - from the Australian reporter hero's first unforgettable encounter with a small British Babycham.

Posted by Peter Stothard on November 06, 2008 at 14:48 in Books | Permalink | Comments (6)

»

  • Weekly book reviews and literary criticism from the Times Literary Supplement

    Subscribe to the TLS for less

    Your writer

    Sir Peter Stothard,
    is Editor of the Times Literary Supplement. Between 1992 and 2002 he was Editor of The Times and in 2003 he wrote Thirty Days, an account of Tony Blair in Downing Street during the Iraq War. His new book, On the Spartacus Road: A Spectacular Journey through Ancient Italy is to be published in January, 2010.


    Send Peter an email


    Subscribe to RSS feed

    Latest posts

    Latest comments

    Categories

    Select from the dropdown

    TLS Links

    • ARLT
    • Art News Blog
    • Arts & Letters Daily
    • The After-Dinner Payback
    • Blogographos
    • Culture Wars
    • EuroTopics
    • Frank Wilson
    • GoldenRuleJones
    • Houyhnhnm Land
    • Kenneth Anderson
    • ReadySteadyBook
    • Real Clear Politics
    • Rogue Classicism
    • SciTech Daily
    • Stephen Mitchelmore
    • The Elegant Variation
    • The Literary Saloon
    • The Little Professor
    • Unspeak
    • Barone blog
    • Brit Lit Blogs
    • Roman history books

    Archives

    • May 2009
    • April 2009
    • March 2009
    • February 2009
    • January 2009
    • December 2008
    • November 2008
    • October 2008
    • September 2008
    • August 2008

    Times Online
    Books

    • Books
    • Book Reviews
    • Book Extracts
    • Books Group
    Other Times Online blogs
    • Alpha Mummy
    • BabyBarista
    • Ariel Leve
    • Big Brother
    • Charles Bremner
    • Comment Central
    • Line and length
    • Formula One
    • India Knight
    • Inside Iraq
    • Mary Beard (TLS)
    • Mick Smith
    • Money Central
    • News
    • Rugby League
    • Sports Commentary
    • Richard Lloyd Parry
    • Ruth Gledhill
    • Tech Central
    • Crime Central
    • Urban Dirt
    • The Game